What Would You Take?

Apr 12, 2012

—

Tent and sun flare

Here’s a not-too-philosophical piece that Laura wrote and which entertained us both no end in Patagonia:

One December, I was leaving Coire Cas car park ready to climb Ben Macdui when I saw a group of Japanese tourists wearing city clothes and carrying Sainsburys’ bags setting off up Cairngorm. They made a sharp contrast to my axes and crampons.

Today we had a similar encounter when we (laden with tent, stove and several days’ food) passed a girl carrying nowt but a sandwich bag containing a bottle of water and a biscuit.

We were on a popular path, but she still seemed laughably underprepared. It led to a conversation about inappropriate items – one food, one drink – to take on a winter skills course. Here are a few of the best:

Cherry Panda Pop and a Chomp

Flask of Bovril and some Chewits

Mars Milk and a packet of Wrigleys Double Mint

Carton of Ribena and a choc ice

Strawberry Yop and some Frazzles

Dehydration ration pack and an apple (ala Sam McConnell)

Can of Lilt and some Fishermen’s Friends

Chocolate Frijj and a boiled egg

Oh, and the Japanese toursts on Cairngorm? They arrived back to the carpark at the same time as us a few hours later. Who knows where they’d been.

Off Topic Patagonia

Comments

5 responses to “What Would You Take?”

Yuki

April 12, 2012

It sort of sounds like everyone was reasonably prepared, if they got back in one piece, city clothes and takeout notwithstanding. Why are you judging people by what they take on what’s obviously just an afternoon stroll for them?

Reminds me of a winter afternoon we spent looking for a Christmas tree at a tree farm. Everyone wandered in, wearing weekender clothes, carrying lattes, waiting in line to get their tree sled and llittle hacksaw, when this dude walks in–dressed for -20C weather, obviously prepared to blog about his big adventure hacking down a mighty pine–and says, “I don’t need a saw, I’ve brought my axe!” and he shows off his gleaming, big, brand new axe. Everyone just looks at him, and the tree farm owner is like, “Buddy, they’re just Christmas trees–we’re not doing any logging here. These trees are way too small for axes.”

Is it possible that you’re that guy?

For the record, I’d take one 500mL water bottle per person, a Thermos of hot chocolate, apples, pears, crackers, cheese, one bag of nuts, and one emergency energy bar per person, for an afternoon hike in woods or hills.

Reply
Yuki

April 12, 2012

…and of course, the water bottle would be reusable, and I’d pack my garbage out with me. (That’s my pet peeve: litter.)

Reply
Tim Moss

April 12, 2012

Thanks for the message Yuki. It wasn’t meant to be taken too seriously. I can’t take credit for your Christmas tree encounter I’m afraid!

Reply
Laura

April 13, 2012

Hi Yuki

As Tim says, it was a joke more than anything, sorry if it wasn’t clear. I agree that being over-prepared can be laughable – all the gear and no idea – but there are certain minimum standards I would expect when heading into the hills, especially in winter. The Cairngorm plateau in winter can be a hostile place (people die there most years) and proper clothing, footwear and navigation aids, in my opinion, are essential. There is a big difference between buying a Christmas tree and wandering around a mountain in deep snow during a white out. I also think, but would need to confirm, that a general duty of care applies in the mountains, meaning that you are obliged to go to the aid of your fellow mountaineers where necessary and possible. Lacking the necessary kit therefore risks not just your own life, but the lives of others out on the hill. I should add that I am in no way an expert and perhaps others would disagree with me.

Reply
Helen

April 19, 2012

I climbed Ben Nevis last May. It was a miserable day, cold and raining. Anything not waterproof got drenched. The top was covered in snow, to the extent that I was wearing a pair of leggings under my walking trousers, which were under my waterproof trousers, and 5 layers on my upper body, as well as a hat and gloves.

I passed numerous people dressed in jeans and/or trainers. Most of them had turned back. I even saw one guy in shorts, though to give him his due, he made it to the top. One friend I climbed with hadn’t brought waterproof trousers and was really suffering with the cold and the wet.

That same day, someone died of hypothermia on the mountain – though Mountain Rescue said he had been reasonably well equipped. Even in Britain, you have to take mountains seriously.

Reply